One Less Sleep for Sox Fans: Yankees Steal Game 2 in Bronx Circus
Boston blew chances, Duran fumbled the routine—and now it’s Game 3 or bust.
Your Boston Red Sox had their wild-card dreams jerked into overtime last night with a 4-3 loss to the Yankees in Game 2, forcing a brutal Game 3 in New York. The season now hinges on one game, one night, one mistake—exactly the sort of pressure cooker Boston fans know too well.
Game Recap: Back-and-Forth, Then the Knife
The story of Game 2 was not “Yankees overwhelmed Boston.” It was “Yankees edged Boston while Boston made enough errors to qualify as theatrical.”
First Inning Shock: Boston handed New York a jolt. Ben Rice crushed a two-run homer off Brayan Bello in his very first bats — yes, his first. And just like that, Boston was trailing before even waking up.
Sox Fight Back: In the top of the third, Trevor Story singled in two runs (Duran and Rafaela) to tie the game at 2–2. That felt satisfying. If only they’d been able to ride it.
Judge Does Judge Things: In the bottom of the fifth, Aaron Judge lined a two-out single scoring Trent Grisham. Routine vs. Boston? Never. That put New York back on top.
Story’s Blast: In the sixth, Story—yes, again—launched a solo shot to even the game 3–3. At least no one could accuse him of not trying. The crowd looked unsettled.
Seventh Inning Chaos: Boston had every chance to take the lead. Rodón lost control, walking men, hitting batters. Rafaela was tasked with a bunt to push a run, but flared it back to the pitcher. That’s a playoff schoolbook error. All that effort, fumbled.
Whitlock Blown in the Eighth: Coming out after a solid stretch, Whitlock retired two batters in the eighth — then gave up a walk to Jazz Chisholm Jr. Then Austin Wells belted a two-out RBI single into right to bust the 3–3 tie. Yanks 4, Sox 3. That was the dagger.
Ninth: A Prayer, Not a Rally: Ceddanne Rafaela lofted a ball to right that might’ve tied it. Maybe. But Aaron Judge corralled it at the wall, denying Boston a final chance. That was the end. 4–3, Yankees.
Players Who Helped (or Hurt) Their Cause
Trevor Story deserves applause. His two-run single and homer kept Boston alive. If you’re going to lose, at least make your arms earn something.
Jarren Duran, however — bless his heart — misplayed what should’ve been a routine fly ball off Judge in the fifth. He dove, the ball glanced off, and Trent Grisham scored. It wasn’t dramatic. It was amateur. Duran said “this one’s on me.” He’s probably right.
Ceddanne Rafaela had the pivotal flop in the seventh. He popped up a bunt attempt. In a game where every little edge matters, that one counts. He also chased a pitch two feet off the plate in the ninth to put himself in a hole versus David Bednar. Yikes.
Garrett Whitlock was sterling most of the night. But come the eighth — when it mattered — he lost command. The walk + single blew the door open. He threw 47 pitches, making it unlikely he’ll be available tonight.
Brayan Bello had the cruelest cut: yanked after just 28 pitches in the third with the game tied. Not exactly how you scheme for postseason glory. Cora said he made that move because the lefties were hitting and bullpen matchups mattered. The optics? Brutal.
What They (or We) Said
Alex Cora: “We were all in … I think a lot went into our decision-making.” Translation: we chose to remove our starter for reasons nobody else can see, and now we’re stuck.
Duran: “I thought I had the read. I screwed up.” Rare humility, but the damage is done.
Whitlock: “I felt good… got tired toward the end.” In relief? In a wild-card game? That excuse only flies in Sandlot.
From the Yankees: They praised their bullpen, especially Cruz and Bednar, for holding Boston’s late threats at bay.
Opponent Blunders? A Few… but They Still Won
Yankees closer David Bednar gave up some contact, but managed to survive. They didn’t have clean innings, but their bullpen made the magic happen when needed.
Their defense wasn’t perfect — some misplays, some off throws — but nothing that dramatically shifted the game.
Their lineup left runners on base. They had chances too. But unlike Boston, they executed in the clutch.
In short: New York didn’t need perfection. They just needed Boston’s mistakes to be bigger than their own.
Momentum Check: Weeping or Reckoning?
Game 1: squeaker win by Boston. Game 2: squeaker win by New York. Now it’s a knife-edge finale. Boston’s momentum? It’s dying under the weight of “what ifs.”
In the AL Wild Card picture, there’s no cushion. This is do-or-die. Boston can’t flirt with errors or leave runners in scoring position. They need a clean performance, or we’ll be headed home.
Game 3 Preview: No Margin, No Mercy
Tonight, Boston hands the ball to rookie Connelly Early, who will carry the entire season in his baggage. One start, one night, one shot. Cora’s declared Early will get the nod. That’s guts. Or desperation. Maybe both.
The Yankees will counter with Cam Schlittler (rookie or not, he’s been good) and their bullpen still looks wired for tight contests.
Boston has to:
Don’t let Judge beat you with his bat alone.
Make routine plays. No Duran dives.
Get a starter who can go deep without bleeding.
Keep Whitlock rested, but also ready.
Don’t overthink it. Sometimes you just have to hit the damn baseball with two strikes.
Subscribe to Red Sox Digest — because if we’re going to relive every gut-punch, someone better write the obituary tonight.