The Red Sox Missed on Bregman… So Now Comes the Eugenio Suárez Panic Button

---

The Boston Red Sox entered the offseason with a plan.
Not a great plan. Not a multi-layered chessboard plan. But a plan nonetheless.

Re-sign Alex Bregman.
Keep the lineup stable.
Pretend the last two years of roster chaos were a fever dream.

Instead? They watched Alex Bregman take his bags, his plate discipline, and his October credibility to the Chicago Cubs— leaving Boston staring at the hot corner like someone just stole their car while they were still in it.

So now we arrive at the pivot.
And Red Sox pivots are rarely graceful.

---

Let’s Be Clear: Losing Bregman Hurt — But It Wasn’t the End of the World

Bregman wasn’t perfect. He wasn’t peak Houston-villain Bregman anymore. But he gave you:

• A professional at-bat

• Actual on-base skills

• A pulse in big moments

• And a third baseman who didn’t make Fenway feel like a live-fire defensive drill

That matters.

And yet, Boston didn’t completely turtle after losing him. Credit where it’s due — the front office did something bold for once.

They went out and signed Ranger Suárez to a five-year, $130 million deal, finally acknowledging that pitching might matter in a division where the Yankees and Orioles treat offense like a recreational activity.

Good move. Legitimate move.
The kind of move that says, “We might actually want to win games.”

But pitching alone doesn’t solve the glaring crater at third base. And now the Sox are linked to the most Red Sox-y fallback option imaginable.

---

Enter Eugenio Suárez: The Power Bat With Warts

Yes — Eugenio Suárez.

The same Eugenio Suárez who strikes out a ton.
The same Eugenio Suárez who hits baseballs into low orbit.
The same Eugenio Suárez who somehow turns Fenway Park into his personal Home Run Derby.

According to Bleacher Report, the Red Sox are one of the best fits for him, with Tim Kelly slotting Boston second on his list of landing spots — right behind the Angels, who collect power hitters the way normal people collect credit card debt.

And honestly? The logic checks out.

Suárez has already mashed at Fenway — four homers, 14 RBI in just 10 career games — which tells you everything you need to know about how his swing plays in that ballpark.

Short porch. Monster. Chaos.
Perfect.

---

This Is Not Bregman. Stop Pretending It Is.

Let’s get something straight before the coping starts.

Eugenio Suárez is not Alex Bregman.

He will not:

• Work long counts

• Grind pitchers into existential crises

• Post a .360 OBP just by breathing

What he will do is hit baseballs extremely hard and extremely far.

In 2025, split between the Diamondbacks and Mariners, Suárez played 159 games and put up:

• 49 home runs

• 118 RBI

• .228/.298/.526 slash line

Yes, the average is ugly.
Yes, the OBP makes analytics Twitter flinch.

But here’s the thing Red Sox fans need to hear:

The current roster needs power more than it needs aesthetics.

You don’t replace Bregman’s profile with a clone. You replace it with impact. And Suárez provides that — loudly.

---

Fenway Doesn’t Care About Your Batting Average

Fenway Park has never asked hitters to be pretty.
It asks them to punish mistakes.

Suárez does that.

Put him behind Anthony and suddenly pitchers have to decide:

• Pitch to Roman and risk Suárez nuking a hanging slider

• Or walk Roman and hope Suárez misses

That’s lineup leverage — something the Red Sox offense has been sorely missing when Devers was the only adult in the room.

Is Suárez a defensive upgrade?
Absolutely not.

Is he a defensive liability?
Also yes.

But let’s not pretend third base defense has been pristine lately. Boston can live with average-to-below-average gloves if the tradeoff is 40+ home run power.

---

The Contract Makes Too Much Sense (Which Is Concerning)

According to Spotrac, Suárez is projected around two years, $29–30 million.

That’s it.

Not five years.
Not $150 million.
Not an opt-out labyrinth.

That’s the kind of deal this front office should jump on — which naturally raises suspicion, because historically they avoid obvious value plays like they’re radioactive.

For context, Bregman’s 2025 line:

• 18 HR

• 62 RBI

• .273/.360/.462 in 114 games

Great player. Real loss. But if you can replace some of that production while injecting elite power at a fraction of the cost? That’s how you build a roster without setting the payroll on fire.

---

Is This a Championship Move? No. Is It a Necessary One? Probably.

Signing Suárez wouldn’t mean the Red Sox “won the offseason.”
It would mean they didn’t punt it.

He could be:

• A one-year bridge

• A two-year stopgap

• A chaos bat who turns Fenway into a nightly event

And frankly, after watching this team spend years trying to win 4–3 games with lineups that go silent for weeks at a time, some controlled chaos might be exactly what’s needed.

---

Final Thought: The Sox Don’t Have to Do This — But They Probably Should

Boston could choose patience.
They could wait for the kids.
They could sell fans on “internal options.”

But if they want to compete now — not in theory, not in 2028 — then Eugenio Suárez is sitting right there, unsigned, affordable, and tailor-made for their ballpark.

No, he’s not Bregman.
But pretending the hole will fill itself is how you end up chasing the Wild Card again.

And Red Sox fans are tired of chasing.

If the front office is serious about pairing that Ranger Suárez signing with real offensive intent?
This is the move.

If not?
Well… enjoy another summer of explaining why “the process” just needs more time.

Subscribe to Red Sox Digest — because somebody has to say the quiet part out loud.